john anglin still alivedavid and kate bagby 2020

You can email her at agraff@sfgate.com. In the center of the picture, directly above the three-inch gun, is the main cell block. The cell is closed showing position of the accordian case blocking the hole and position of the false head on the pillow. Retrieved October 13, 2015. From there, the trail grew cold. A new photo has surfaced that allegedly proves Alcatraz inmates John and Clarence Anglin didn't die during their infamous 1962 escape and actually survived--but the lone official investigator. My grandmother received roses for several years after the escape. If Anglin is still alive today, he would be nearly 90. A laminated print out hangs on the wall at the Ranger office on Alcatraz with images of Frank Morris, John Anglin, Clarence Anglin as well as photos where they've been aged. 2012-06-12. Officials turned to the other incarcerated Anglin brother, Alfred, who was housed in an Alabama facility, to see if he knew anything. examples of successful teams in business; westboro baptist church lauren; geraldton guardian funeral notices; wild burger riverbanks zoo menu Alcatraz Island with small boat in back of the prison on Jan 18, 1952. Now, KPIX has made public a letter reportedly sent to a San Francisco Police Department station in the Richmond neighborhood in 2013. This photo, taken by Fred Brizzi, provided evidence that the Anglin brothers may have made it South America. And few if any sharks would have threatened them: That was primarily a scare tactic employed by the prison to dissuade escape attempts. Marshals Service to this day continues to have an open case on the escape. Jump up ^ Amy Graff (October 12, 2015). She previously worked for CBS San Francisco and SPIN Magazine and has contributed to Good Beer Hunting, Paper, Vice's i-D and Paste, among others. A display case holds some of the items the guards carried. Come daylight, the illusion stopped working. There were unconfirmed reports that the raft was found on Angel Island. If they did manage to make it, theyd be in need of clothes, food, and other supplies, yet no crimes or strange activity tied to the escape aside from the suspicious stolen Chevy were ever discovered by the FBI. "Escape From Alcatraz: June 11, 1962". Shackled together (left to right): Clarence Carnes, 19, Sam Shockley and Miran Thompson are led from an elevator in the San Francisco Federal building on June 25, 1946 en route to court in custody of a U.S. In 1956, the boys were caught and arrested. Among the experts was a photo and facial recognition analyst who determined the photograph of the two men to be John and Clarence Anglin. An FBI laboratory examined the letter for fingerprints and DNA, and analyzed the handwriting within, but the results were inconclusive. Banghart and fellow inmate Alvin Karpis worked the kitchen where they were known as the ""Karpis Kitchen Crew." "If John is still alive, he'd be 91 years old. I have cancer. Marshals Service to this day continues to have an open case on the escape. They reportedly learned how to make wine from cherry pie juices. This 1962 photo from the U.S. Penitentiary Alcatraz shows Frank Morris' cell and shows the entire back of the cell with the accordion case that was blocking the avenue of escape. Experts who compared the letters handwriting to that of John Anglins, and to the Christmas cards which the Anglin family received noted consistency and the likelihood that it was legitimate. Marshals Service to this day continues to have an open case on the escape. The U.S. Marshals Service to this day continues to have an open case on the escape. On June 11, 1962, Frank Morris and brothers Clarence and John Anglin all bank robbers carried out a daring, intricate plan to escape Alcatraz. Sisters of the Anglin brothers, Marie Anglin Widner (left) and Mearl AnglinTaylor (right) show an article where a woman, Eugenia MacGowan received a call alleging that the Anglin brothers had survived the escape during their visit to Alcatraz on the 50th anniversary of the Anglin Brothers escape in San Francisco, California, on Monday, June 11, 2012. This blood-splattered cell was where rioting convicts held several Alcatraz penitentiary guards hostage during the early hours of the attempted prison break on May 2, 1946. Escape from Alcatraz. After forensic analysis was performed, the photo was determined to be authentic. Marie remembers her brothers - John William (J.W. The Sun website is regulated by the Independent Press Standards Organisation (IPSO), Our journalists strive for accuracy but on occasion we make mistakes. Investigators estimated that Morris and the Anglin brothers set out into the thick fog just after 10 oclock. And now federal officials are asking citizens to be on the lookout. Allen West was played by Larry Hankin; his character's name was changed to Charlie Butts. Replica dummies, like the ones made by the only known escapees of Alcatraz, Frank Morris and brothers John and Clarence Anglin, are seen in a cell on Alcatraz Island June 8th, 2012. Long before the advent of internet sleuths and true crime specials, the country would be transfixed with their audacious bid for freedomand whether they had really made it out alive. A week later, authorities found remnants of the raincoats used for the raft and life preservers. Retrieved 2012-06-12. In this lineup of convicts leaving the recreation yard of Alcatraz from August 1938, prisoners like Machine Gun Kelly and Al Capone, the toughest prisoners in America, start the day on the island. They finally decided that based on expert opinion the convicts sank to the bottom of San Francisco Bay. Along with accomplice Morris, the bank robbing Anglin brothers crept out of their cells via holes dug for months with spoons. This is no joke.. In 2013, a letter claiming to be from John Anglin was sent to the San Francisco Police Department. The doppelgngers were convincing enough to fool the guards the evening of June 11, 1962. By then, all three men were long gone. Horoscope for Friday, 3/03/23 by Christopher Renstrom, No seriously, dont drive up to Tahoe this weekend, Horoscope for Saturday, 3/04/23 by Christopher Renstrom, Snowboarder dies at Tahoe ski resort following historic blizzard, Wife of Jeffrey Vandergrift issues somber update, The Warriors broke Russell Westbrook, just like old times, Oakland ransomware attackers leak 'confidential' data, Mochi muffin bakery closes SF cafe after just 4 months, Even Salesforces tower HQ isnt safe from office cuts, Scream publicity stunt floods Bay Area dispatch with 911 calls, The best fried chicken is at a San Francisco strip club, 10 beach essentials to pack for a spring break vacation, In search of vegan food, I found a world-class Mendocino inn, Your Privacy Choices (Opt Out of Sale/Targeted Ads). Its preserved almost perfectly, with the same gaping hole in its teal-painted wallbut even the scene of the crime offers few answers as to where these great escapees wound up. Retrieved 2008-12-07. By Nupur Kudapkar. The FBI lab analysed the letter for DNA and fingerprints but their results were inconclusive, according to local reports. The Widners also handed over Christmas cards signed with Clarence and John's names which were delivered to their mother, with no postage, for three consecutive years after the escape. Three convicts, Bernard Coy, a bank robber from Kentucky; Joseph Paul Cretzer, a bank robber from Los Angeles; and Marvin Hobbard, a kidnapper from Tennessee, were killed. Both brothers were sentenced to 15-20 years behind bars. Is one of the infamous 1962 Alcatraz escapees still alive? The trio absconded into a utility hall behind their cells and climbed their way up to leave through the roof. In December 1961, the men began using makeshift toolslike a drill powered by a vacuum cleaner motorto remove the air vents and a portion of the surrounding wall in their cells. It didnt take long before the four convicts began plotting a coordinated effort to escape. To give themselves a headstart, the men used a mixture of soap, toothpaste, concrete dust, and toilet paper to create a home-made paper-mache. It had no lights on, but appeared to have someone on board shining a flashlight into the water. "I know Frank Morris was with them in 1975. Twice a week we compile our most fascinating features and deliver them straight to you. "I've seen the picture. The U.S. Does this photo prove John and Clarence Anglin survived their 1962 Alcatraz escape? My name is John Anglin, it read. The Anglins were known to be strong swimmers as kids; Morris was said to have engaged in an intense exercise regimen to prepare for the effort. (1963). BBC. Please enable JavaScript in your browser's settings to use this part of Geni. George Robert Anglin Sr, Rachel Van Anglin (born Miller). On June 11, 1962, three prisoners escaped from U.S. Penitentiary Alcatraz in San Francisco, using dummies in there cells and other complicated methods. Monday, June 11th marks the 50th anniversary of the escape of three prisoners from U.S. Penitentiary Alcatraz in San Francisco, Calif. Connect to the World Family Tree to find out, Apr 1 1950 - Blacktop Road, Gibsonton, Hillsborough, Florida, United States, bert Anglin, Alfred Ray Anglin, Clarence Anglin, Christine Anglin, Carson Anglin, Marie Anglin, Mearl Anglin, Patsy Anglin, Mary Nell Anglin, May 2 1930 - Miller County, United States, June 11 1962 - Alcatraz Island, United States, May 2 1930 - Seminole, Georgia, United States. John and Clarence never intended to hurt anyone, so they typically went for closed targets. But the Anglins had another advantage. (Alcatraz itself closed in 1963, not because its reputation as an escape-proof purgatory diminished but because its upkeep became too expensive to sustain.) Unsourced material may be challenged and removed. Nat Farbman/Time & Life Pictures/Getty Image. The Widners also shared the image with the History Channel that aired the special "Alcatraz: Search for the Truth" last night. John was sent to Alcatraz after being caught attempting escape from the state penitentiary; he arrived on October 21, 1960, as Alcatraz inmate AZ1476, and Clarence arrived on January 10, 1961, as Alcatraz inmate AZ1485. He would later cooperate fully with investigators and provide them with every detail of the inmates plan to avoid any punishment for his own involvement in the escape. Clickheretouploadyours. I don't ever put 100 percent stock in what I hear. More than 70 years after Capone penned it, somebody recorded the song. The important thing is to not draw any conclusions as it hasn't been vetted through regular investigative channels.". Alfred likely knew as much or as little as anyone else, yet when his body was exhumed it showed no signs of physical abuse. By 1979, the FBI had officially closed its case. This 1962 photo from the U.S. Penitentiary Alcatraz shows John Anglin's cell and shows the entire cell with the method of concealing the escape method and and the dummy head used. "[They're] more on the natively cunning side, throwbacks to the swamp country, more given to action," he said. With an intelligence level reportedly ranking among the top 2% of the entire human population, and an IQ of 133, Frank Morris was presumed to be the brains behind the operation. I have cancer. The U.S. That obviously made communicationand plotting their escapemuch easier. If the men are. Clarence (l.) and John Anglin (r.) escaped from Alcatraz in 1962. John and Clarence Anglin were born in Donalsonville, Georgia into a family of 13 kids. Alcatraz Federal Penitentiary was famously one of the most unforgiving prisons of the 20th century. Marshals Service to this day continues to have an open case on the escape. With Clint Eastwood starring as Frank Morris, Jack Thibeau portraying Clarence Anglin, and Fred Ward playing John Anglin, Escape From Alcatraz gives the audience a glimpse into one of the most miraculous prison escapes of all time. The rioting ended with two guards dead, one if them in this cell. A view from the 1930's of the Alcatraz island and penitentiary, in San Francisco Bay. "The picture that 'proves' two inmates DID escape from Alcatraz: Notorious escapees didn't drown, body-surfed behind a passenger ferry to freedom and started a farm in Brazil, claims family". This is no joke The FBI did no such thing, and instead repressed the letter. FBI wanted poster The official report on the escape says the prisoners drowned in the bay but since then, there have been reports that there was an illegal boat in the bay on the night of the escape, that there have been sightings of the three men and that friends and family members have received many unsigned postcards and messages. On June 11 the escape began with Morris and the Anglins climbing up the ventilation shaft through one of the chimneys and reaching the top of the roof. I escape from Alcatraz in June 1962 with my brother Clarence and Frank Morris. The only weapon they ever used was a toy gun. People view Alcatraz through powerful telescopes on June 16, 1962. Its always been talked about through the family, David Widner, a nephew of John and Clarence Anglin, told CBS. Police followed up on the sighting, but couldnt find the owner of this strange boator where it went next. "I'm 83 years old and in bad shape. This 1962 photo from the U.S. Penitentiary Alcatraz shows correctional officer Orrin T. Maybee looking over the inside of the escape hole and the cover fashioned by the prisoners. They clambered up a drainpipe and down a kitchen vent and climbed over two fences with barbed wire. After roughly six months of plotting and effort, the men were ready to ruin the prisons reputation. Cell #138 "B" Block in Alcatraz is the cell that housed Frank Morris until his escape. John Paul Scott was one of two Alcatraz inmates who broke out of prison on December 16, 1962. According to KPIX 5, the FBI first learned of the letter after it was sent to the San Francisco Police Department's Richmond station in 2013. . She is a Bay Area native and graduate of New York University and SFSU. Today, it plays host to more than a million tourists each year, often drawn to the site by the story of the Anglin brothers, which was adapted for the screen in the 1979 film Escape From Alcatraz. New evidence presented in a 2015 History Channel special shows a photo allegedly showing escaped brothers John and Clarence Anglin in Brazil - 13 years after the great escape. The fate of these three men and their makeshift vessel has long been questioned. Monday, June 11th marks the 50th anniversary of the escape of three prisoners from U.S. Penitentiary Alcatraz in San Francisco, Calif. Authorities, however, are not convinced. While guards stand by on the roof tear gas and grenade smoke shroud the cell block at Alcatraz in San Francisco Bay on May 3, 1946, as action against rioting convicts, cornered in the building, continued. We pay forvideostoo. Brizzi, a friend of the Anglins, claimed the men had not only survived their escape attempt but had made it to South America. A photo of Al Capone and sheet music for a song "Madonna Mia" written in pencil by Capone while he was at Alcatraz prison. ), American criminal who escaped in 1962 from Alcatraz Federal Penitentiary John Anglin (sailor) (1850-1905), cabin boy in US Navy, received Medal of Honor This disambiguation page lists articles about people with the same name. Basil Banghart, a machine gunner during the Prohibition era, served more than 11 years at Alcatraz Federal Prison and transferred to Joliet State Prison in Illinois in 1954. Both had also tried to run from chain gangs. . HISTORY reviews and updates its content regularly to ensure it is complete and accurate. However, there have long been mumblings from those who think the prisoners who would be in their 80s and 90s now might still be out there. Alcatraz Island June 8th, 2012. Marshals investigating the case told the broadcaster they considered the lead closed with no merit, and a simple hoax from someone hoping to scam and embarrass federal and local authorities. John William Anglin From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia For the American Civil War sailor, see John Anglin (Medal of Honor). US Marshalls have released the pictures of Frank Morris, Clarence Anglin and his brother, John Anglin by a forensic artist. I know of times that they came to America to visit the family. Prisoner Arthur Barker was convicted of theft, robbery, murder, and kidnapping. Menu; Rechercher; Culture; Sante; Numrique; Divers; A propos; Rechercher. The government agency joined the Bureau of Prisons and the Coast Guard to mount a massive investigation. Yes we all made it that night but barely! "New claim: Alcatraz escapees might have survived. This newly-found piece of evidence might just be the biggest breakthrough in the entire history of the 56-year-old investigation. Detroit Newstime. Monday, June 11th marks the 50th anniversary of the escape of three prisoners from U.S. Penitentiary Alcatraz in San Francisco, Calif. I don't think John would have agreed to serve a year to get medical attention. In it, Anglin claimed that Morris had died in 2008 and his brother in 2011. In 2014, a team of Dutch researchers decided to use computer models to simulate the bays conditions on the night of the escape and determine the prisoners likelihood of survival. Based on the information gathered from the scene, as well as from West, officials discovered that the Anglins and Morris had gained entry to the roof via another ventilator shaft, then shimmied down to ground level. could still be alive". In the attempted prison escape, May 2-4, 1946, two guards and three inmates were killed. Young and McCain were recaptured. Monday, June 11th marks the 50th anniversary of the escape of three prisoners from U.S. Penitentiary Alcatraz in San Francisco, Calif. Inside the Chevy, witnesses claim, were three men. Marshals is the only agency still conducting an active investigation on the case. Amy Graff is the news editor for SFGATE. If the letter was, in fact, written by John Anglin, the case could potentially be re-opened by the FBI. Morris, who would be 95 today, would be the first to cross that threshold, followed by John and then Clarence, who were born in 1930 and 1931, respectively. In the years since, nearly six decades of silence from the men led many to conclude that the escape had met a watery end. If the letter was written by John Anglin, and if the escaped convict is still alive, he would now be in his late 80s. The U.S. Two prisoners, Mickey Cohen and Ellsworth Bumpy Johnson, were suspected of arranging for a boat to be waiting for the men once they reached the mainland. With nowhere to run and no way of leaving the island alone, West had no option but to return to his cell. After all, he could just be trying to steer the investigation away from the Anglins actual location. Marshal Michael Dyke, based in Oakland, said in an interview. Evidence is now piling up that the three men survived and one even lived in Fargo. A morning head count revealed just thatfake heads but no bodies to go along with them. On June 11, 1962, the trio successfully escaped the maximum security prison. A wanted poster for renowned Alcatraz escapee Clarence Anglin. Following the Civil War, the island was modified and fortified, with the addition of a brick jailhouse. leduc county property assessment map. Brizzi took a photograph of the brothers, which he planned to show to the Anglin family and let them know their boys were alive. Monday, June 11th marks the 50th anniversary of the escape of three prisoners from U.S. Penitentiary Alcatraz in San Francisco, Calif. But what happened next has stumped historians for decades. The boats patrolling off the island were to ensure that no convicts escaped by water and to lend firepower. Their bodies were never recovered, leaving many wondering whether they perished in the choppy San Francisco Bay or made it to shoreand freedom. Their swimming skills and cold water tolerance would eventually pay off in a big way. FACT CHECK: We strive for accuracy and fairness. While West was running into trouble, Morris and the Anglins were executing their plan flawlessly. Jump up ^ "ALCATRAZ: SEARCH FOR THE TRUTH". At the request of the U.S. A 2013 letter to the FBI, if real, suggests the Anglin brothers and Frank Morris survived one of the most daringand dangerousprison breaks of all time. This 1962 photo from the U.S. Penitentiary Alcatraz shows Frank Morris's cell and shows the entire back of the cell with the accordian case that was blocking the avenue of escape. (June 2008) John Anglin John Anglin - head shot - 01.jpg Born May 2, 1930 Donalsonville, Georgia Disappeared June 11, 1962 (aged 32) Alcatraz John William Anglin born (May 2, 1930) is or was an American criminal and folk culture figure who took part in the infamous June 1962 Alcatraz escape. For brothers John and Clarence Anglin, the story of the most infamous prison escape in modern history began with a toy gun. This 1962 photo from the U.S. Penitentiary Alcatraz shows correctional officer Orrin T. Maybee looking over the vent, grill and cover used as an escape exit. [5] According to Unsolved Mysteries, a day after the escape a man claiming to be John Anglin had called a lawyer in San Francisco and wanted the lawyer to arrange a meeting with the US Marshals' Office. An old family friend brought the photograph to the Anglin. If the men are still alive they will be aged over 90. Alcatraz inmate John Giles attempted to escape in 1945. Aerial view dated 1930's of the Alcatraz island and penitentiary, in the San Francisco Bay. There, the escapees had the privacy to work on the other major part of their plan: constructing a raft and life preservers. The FBI was stumped. Merry Christmas. Authorities then confirmed that there was, in fact, a chance that the runaway convicts survived. On the night of June 11, 1962, Morris, West, and the Anglins set out to make history. The U.S. ', News Group Newspapers Limited in England No. Small windows were all that afforded prisioners a view of the City. Now the family of John and Clarence Anglin say a photograph taken in 1975 shows the brothers alive and well and living in Brazil. The trio then climbed down the rooftop, pumped up their rubber raft and then paddled away into the night, never to be seen again. It was believed they then attempted to paddle to freedom from Alcatraz Island on a raft made from 50 raincoats. October 12, 2015. "I can't say yes or no on it,"U.S. Now, over half a century later, a new piece of evidence has come to the Deputys attention. The distance from Alcatraz to Angel Island is well over a mile, which would make for a difficult trip in the cold current of the San Francisco Bay. The Federal Bureau of Prisons say that they drowned once they got off of Alcatraz and their bodies were swept out to the Pacific Oceanend of story, National Park Service Ranger John Cantwell said. With so few leads to go on, a nationwide manhunt for the Anglins produced nothing in the way of evidence they had made it. Widner expressed dismay that authorities had not contacted the family about his relative's alleged. (Discuss) Proposed since October 2015. [8][9][10][11], See also[edit] List of Alcatraz escape attempts List of people who disappeared mysteriously Theodore Cole and Ralph Roe References[edit] Jump up ^ Pruitt, Sarah (October 9, 2015). Horoscope for Friday, 3/03/23 by Christopher Renstrom, No seriously, dont drive up to Tahoe this weekend, Horoscope for Saturday, 3/04/23 by Christopher Renstrom, Snowboarder dies at Tahoe ski resort following historic blizzard, Wife of Jeffrey Vandergrift issues somber update, The Warriors broke Russell Westbrook, just like old times, Oakland ransomware attackers leak 'confidential' data, Mochi muffin bakery closes SF cafe after just 4 months, Even Salesforces tower HQ isnt safe from office cuts, Scream publicity stunt floods Bay Area dispatch with 911 calls, The best fried chicken is at a San Francisco strip club, 10 beach essentials to pack for a spring break vacation, In search of vegan food, I found a world-class Mendocino inn, Your Privacy Choices (Opt Out of Sale/Targeted Ads). US Marshall Michael Dyke (left) talks about the tips he follows while searching for the whereabouts of the Anglin Brothers on Alcatraz in San Francisco, California. There were no other missing people during that time period, said Dyke. Between 1934 and 1963, a total of 36 inmates attempted 14 separate escapes. He would be willing to turn himself in if authorities promised him only one year in jail and medical care. On June 14th, the Coast Guard found a paddle 200 yards from Angel Islands southern coast. [2]. Anglin, along with his brother John Anglin and Frank Morris, escaped from Alcatraz on June 11, 1962. The prisoners overpowered guards in the cell house and captured weapons. After a 17-year investigation, the FBI closed the file of the three convicts on December 31, 1979, determining that the runaway prisoners most likely drowned in the frigid waters and brutal current. John Anglin was imprisoned at the Federal Penitentiary in Lewisburg, Pa., while Clarence was shipped to the United States Prison in Leavenworth, Kan. After discovery of a planned escape. The authorities ended the battle with a combined assault of guards from other Federal prisons and military forces. We provide you with the latest breaking news and videos straight from the entertainment industry. Internet Movie Database. He served his term there from 1934-39. If alive today, John would be 85 years old and Clarence would be 84. Marshals Service released a statement saying, There is absolutely no reason to believe that any of them would have changed their lifestyle and became completely law-abiding citizens after this escape.. In fact, inmate John Paul Scott made his escape in December 1962, just months after the Anglins and Morris fled. Contents [hide] 1 Early years 2 Alcatraz 3 Popular culture 4 See also 5 References 6 External links Early years[edit] John Anglin and his brother Clarence Anglin were born in Miller County (Colquitt) Georgia to a family with 14 children (7 boys and 7 girls), spent some of their life in Donalsonville, Seminole County Georgia and then moved to Florida. Marshal Art Roderick, the investigators had their doubts. The authenticity of the correspondence was never proven, and the FBI appeared to keep the letter private until 2018. With this photo, I'm not swaying one way or the other. Roderick had the photo analyzed by a forensic artist who concluded the men in the photo are likely John and Clarence Anglin. "I wa. Relatives were interviewed to determine whether they had been given any outside assistance; a patrol of the waters turned up bits of rubber and wooden paddles, as well as a packet of letters sealed in rubber; one of the homemade life preservers washed ashore on the beach at nearby Fort Cronkhite. West finally arrived on the roof and quickly realized that Morris, the Anglin brothers, and all of the makeshift equipment that the men had prepared were nowhere to be found. Monday, June 11th marks the 50th anniversary of the escape of three prisoners from U.S. Penitentiary Alcatraz in San Francisco, Calif. Brizzi passed the photo to the Anglin family in 1992, and they kept it under wraps until now. Three convicts were not in their cells: John Anglin,. He spent years piecing together an Army uniform from the Army laundry that was delivered to the docks. We pay for your stories! Above all, he's a planner. The cell is closed showing position of the accordian case blocking the hole and position of the false head on the pillow. They recently gave it to ex-US marshal Art Roderick, who headed a 20-year probe into the escape, saying it was taken by family friend Fred Brizzi. Later that day and in a nearby location, a search team found a plastic-wrapped wallet with photos, names, and addresses of the Anglins family and friends. But that was far from the end of the story. The idea was to be prepared for the choppy Bay waters en route to freedom in nearby Marin County. Ken, his nephew, today told The Sun Online: "If he needed help he could have gone down to a hospital or a doctor and no-one would have even known who he was. From May 24, 1946, six prisoners led a failed attempt to escape, which became known as the "Battle of Alcatraz." In June 1962, just one year before the prison shut down, three inmates- Frank Morris, John Anglin, and Clarence Anglin-planned and executed an escape attempt.

Ingento Paper Cutter Replacement Parts, Great Pyrenees Border Collie Mix, 1988 Jamaican Bobsled Team Crash Injuries, Articles J

john anglin still alive

john anglin still aliveClick Here to Leave a Comment Below

Leave a Reply: